What I Got Wrong About Trump Voters: A Reflection on Division and Common Ground
Like many people, I’ve spent years grappling with the rise of Donald Trump, his rhetoric, and the movement he galvanized. I thought I understood it: Trump was a magnet for racists, misogynists, and bigots. His appeal, in my mind, was rooted in the worst parts of society — anger, prejudice, and the desire to turn back the clock on progress.
But now, after his most recent election win, I’m rethinking this narrative. I was wrong to dismiss Trump’s supporters as a monolith of hate and ignorance. The reality is more complex, and, frankly, harder to confront.
A Convenient Narrative
It’s easy to label Trump’s base as inherently racist because racism is part of the dialogue. His rhetoric emboldens and enables it, no question. But I’m starting to think that many of the attitudes we see aren’t rooted in race at all, but in something deeper — issues of class, alienation, and culture wars stoked by the powerful to keep us divided.
This isn’t to say racism doesn’t exist among his supporters; it clearly does. But it’s important to distinguish between those whose racism defines their worldview and those who are swept up in narratives that frame others — immigrants, minorities, or liberals — as threats. Many Trump voters I’ve written off may not even agree with everything he says; instead, they see him as someone who speaks to their anger, frustration, and disillusionment in a world that feels increasingly out of reach.
How the Powerful Divide Us
The real enemy, I’m beginning to see, isn’t each other — it’s the system that keeps us pitted against one another. For decades, the rich and powerful have used culture wars to ensure we stay distracted and divided.
For the right, the narrative is that the left wants to turn everyone into “communist perverts,” erase traditional values, and make them feel ashamed of their way of life. For the left, the story is that the right is filled with “Nazis and gun nuts” who want to destroy democracy and drag society backward.
Both of these narratives have some truth to them — but only enough to keep the fires of division burning. They obscure the fact that, at our core, most of us just want to go outside, be part of a community, and live fulfilling lives.
Shared Struggles, Overlooked Humanity
When I peel back the layers of rhetoric and propaganda, I see people on both sides struggling with the same fundamental issues. Economic instability. A loss of identity and purpose. Fear of change that feels too fast and too alien.
Racism, sexism, and bigotry are real and need to be called out wherever they exist. But they’re often symptoms of deeper fears and frustrations — ones that are amplified by a system designed to keep us fighting each other instead of addressing the root causes.
When I see Trump voters through this lens, I feel remorse for dismissing them outright. I feel regret for failing to see their humanity and for assuming the worst instead of asking, Why?
Breaking the Cycle
If we’re ever going to move forward, we need to stop letting those in power dictate the terms of our divisions. We need to approach each other with empathy, even when it feels uncomfortable or undeserved.
Empathy doesn’t mean excusing hate or ignorance, but it does mean trying to understand where it comes from. It means recognizing that most people, whether on the left or right, aren’t caricatures — they’re just human beings trying to navigate a chaotic world.
We also need to focus on the real enemies: unchecked corporate greed, wealth inequality, and the political machines that benefit from our polarization. If we could unite around shared struggles instead of fighting over manufactured cultural battles, imagine the power we’d have.
A Final Thought
I was wrong about Trump voters, and I’ll own that. I let the easy narrative — the one that felt righteous and satisfying — overshadow the messy, complicated truth.
But if there’s one thing I’ve learned, it’s this: The world isn’t going to change unless we’re willing to change the way we see each other. And that starts with a little humility, a little curiosity, and a willingness to find common ground — even when it feels impossible.
Thank you for reading! Want more content? Find me on
- Medium: https://medium.com/@paulbrzeski
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/paul-b-23620b209/
- Website: https://www.paulbrzeski.com
- YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@paulbrzeski4237/
